Tracing Social Differentiation: Debates and Fieldwork Practices
Patrick Illien & Helena Pérez Niño
The study of social differentiation lies at the heart of agrarian studies, and of agrarian political economy in particular, tracing back to the foundational work of Lenin and Chayanov. However, the methodological challenges that arise in field-based research on social differentiation have not been explored in detail. Our new article in the Journal of Agrarian Change entitled ‘From Theory to the Field and Back Again: Fieldwork-Based Research on Social Differentiation in Agrarian Studies’ provides an overview of the main strategies researchers use to observe and analyze social differentiation in agrarian studies, drawing on a review of 83 fieldwork-based journal articles—selected from an initial pool of 670 articles in agrarian political economy and agrarian social differentiation.
By examining how researchers go about studying social differentiation, we identify two main approaches: First, a stratification approach that groups respondents according to their common individual (or household) socio-economic characteristics, and second, a relational approach that studies social interactions and their distributional implications to identify the resulting groups (for examples of both approaches, refer to the annex of the article).
In the stratification approach, the common characteristics of groups may be suggested by theory or empirically derived from the collected data. Central to this approach is the exercise of grouping individuals or households according to a set of criteria across which all are evaluated. Widely used indicators of agrarian socio-economic differentiation include asset-ownership, wealth, income, consumption and savings or investment. The relational approach goes beyond the identification of groups of households or individuals and instead stresses the nature of the relations taking place. Like stratification analysis, relational analysis is ultimately concerned with mapping and explaining socio-economic change in agrarian social formations, but it often does so in a more theory-driven way. A range of frameworks can be applied here (class analysis, feminist political economy, etc.) but importantly, the theoretical framework determines which relations to observe in fieldwork and will hypothesize what groupings could emerge.
The classification of households into groups is a useful starting point for all kinds of fieldwork on social differentiation in agrarian studies. In addition, both stratification and relational approaches can be used to trace changes over time and to insert these groups into wider socio-economic, ecological, political and historical contexts. However, what distinguishes these two approaches is what they do analytically with the resulting groupings. The stratification approach uses the classification to describe the common experiences of people within these groups and to discern patterns in material wealth and reproductive or livelihood strategies. In contrast, the relational approach uses the classification to trace the distributional outcomes of social relations, their development over time, and how these relations are experienced.
In practice, the boundaries between these two approaches are fuzzy, and many researchers combine them eclectically. This syncretism is a welcome development but raises important methodological questions: For example, although the most widely used measures of material welfare provide valuable information about households and individuals and offer a useful starting point for understanding the relations they engage in, on their own, they can neither explain the differences between households nor shed light on the nature of the relations between them. Tools to investigate labour and class relations can overcome some of these limitations, but there is little discussion in the literature about their methodological application to the study of agrarian social differentiation. In general, there remains a conceptual and methodological gap in that fieldwork activities tend to concentrate on the study of discrete household groups, and there have not been many discussions about how to observe and study relations in a more direct manner.
We suggest that embracing the relational approach to the study of social differentiation allows for the ‘denaturalization of social differentiation’. By this, we mean an approach to social differentiation that is historically contingent and rejects treating the existence of given socioeconomic groups as inherent or as a given. The emergence of social groups is neither inevitable nor functional to capital, but a social construction based on systemic tendencies in interaction with local histories, ecologies and societies. Even though material conditions inform these processes and give rise to underlying tendencies, households with a given set of characteristics are not a priori a group in a social vacuum but only emerge as a group as a consequence of interactions with other households and actors.
We argue that a mechanistic reading would miss the ways in which group relations are thus co-constructed, resisted or transformed and why they take different forms in different settings. In short, social groupings cannot be directly deducted from the distribution of assets, income or labour power (i.e., what households have and do[1]). Instead, the relevance of studying asset distribution and labour use lies in being able to observe through these relations:
- how households interact;
- what relations households enter into and on what terms;
- what social groups emerge from these interactions;
- what group identities and interests form; and
- how groups clash or cooperate.
We claim that a relational lens can trace how historical and political processes (both at micro and macro levels) shape patterns of differentiation in ways that an asset-centric approach cannot.
If enquiry into social differentiation focuses its attention on social relations rather than on household characteristics, these same households can be situated in a richer and more complex web of coordinates, not limited to the unidimensional metric of asset ownership. On a similar note, analysis of social differentiation that has relations at the centre is better suited to recognize how socioeconomic relations intersect with similarly determinant social structures such as gender, kinship, generation, caste, race and ethnicity. In sum, the stratification of households according to discrete variables can measure the socio-economic outcomes of these intersections but cannot discern the character of such interactions.
In order to shift the focus of research from discrete household characteristics (assets, incomes and activities) to inter-household and social relations (of production, exchange and social reproduction), fieldwork exercises could more explicitly decentre individual households by focusing on intergroup or intra-household relations, engaging participants specifically about those relationships and embedding their findings into the analysis of agrarian change. Concretely, this is a call for fieldwork practices to:
- enquire specifically about the relations in which households participate;
- triangulate sources of information and methods; and
- trace how these relations create, maintain, reverse or reshape processes of social differentiation.
We hope that our contribution inspires researchers to explore the exciting methodological questions that arise from the rich theoretical and empirical tapestry of the corpus of critical agrarian studies in the past decades, and to develop concrete frameworks that advance our understanding of processes of social differentiation.
Patrick Illien is a postdoctoral researcher at ETH Zurich’s Food Systems Economics and Policy Group in Switzerland. His research takes a political economy perspective and focuses on economic development, labour relations and agrarian change using a range of quantitative and qualitative methods.
Helena Pérez Niño is Assistant Professor in Political Economy at the International Institute of Social Studies (ISS Erasmus University Rotterdam). Her research on the political economy of development traces the interactions between the social organization of production and the globalization of agricultural markets.
[1] In the article we take issue specifically with the mechanistic use in part of the literature of Henry Bernstein’s influential ‘Four Key Questions’ (2010).