Climate Breakdown, Green Transitions, Food and the Land Question
Benjamin Selwyn
The land (or agrarian) question in the 21st century will become increasingly bound up with the climate question and the broader environment question. In the contemporary context – of climate breakdown and attempts by states, corporations and social movements to respond to it – the land question involves at least the following elements: continued strategies by capital to pursue forms of land and agriculture-based accumulation; the role of states in re-organising land-based accumulation to a) respond to a rising world population, and b) mitigate climate breakdown; and social movements’ attempts to shape eco-social relations on the land and beyond to facilitate a more rather than less ‘just’/green transition.
Quite clearly, there are various and potentially conflicted objectives here, which will complicate attempts to mitigate climate breakdown by re-organising eco-social relations on the land and beyond. This blog represents a (limited) thought-experiment, designed to motivate discussions about different social forces involved in trying to shape the land question in the 21st century. It aims to highlight some of the socio-political forces involved in attempting to shape ways in which eco-social relations on the land will be re-organised in response to climate breakdown.
If international climate summits are anything to go by, then last year’s COP28 placed the food question firmly on the policy and political agenda. For years, the global food system – responsible for roughly 30% of greenhouse gas emissions – has failed to appear as a key item of discussion and planning at the various climate summits. That changed in 2023 as COP28 caught up with activists, civil society organisations and many intellectuals and politicians who have been stressing the centrality of the food system to potential solutions to global environmental destruction and climate breakdown.
The question, though, is how the world food system is understood, and how it will be changed to meet the challenges of climate breakdown? In short, ways in which food systems are reorganised in response to this existential challenge will have profound eco-social implications for the world’s population in the 21st century and probably beyond. There is, of course, always the option that COP28’s recognition is sidelined in what seems to be state leaders’ inability to either comprehend or deal with the enormity of the global environmental crisis.
But if there is movement on this question, what will it look like? It could be more or less progressive, and/or reactionary. It depends, to a significant extent, on the forces driving forward changes to the system. I see potentially four scenarios emerging, each with particular constellations of class forces:
Social Forces and Changes to the World Food System (in approximate order of power and influence)
- Big Agribusiness
- Authoritarian States
- Food Sovereignty/ La Via Campesina-type Movements
- Worker-inspired or led movements
The first possible direction of change could be driven by increasingly authoritarian states. While the far right is often associated with climate-denial, it is not impossible to imagine a situation where it realises that a) climate breakdown threatens its own future, and b) that its own interests (of preserving and deepening its power base) could be served by implementing what appear to be solutions to environmental/climate breakdown. As Joel Wainright and Geoff Mann show, such solutions could entail using state power to police populations’ food and energy consumption in authoritarian ways, and to boost authoritarian politics.
A second option would be that environmental preservation is increasingly allocated to multinational corporations. The latter could be handed responsibility for using new food production technologies (such as alternatives to meat), ‘smarter’ forms of meat production (e.g. use of lower methane-generating feedstocks), shifts towards lower-impact meat production (e.g. from beef to poultry). Here the ready-made notion of ‘climate-smart agriculture’ (CSA) could be used to justify handing responsibility to such corporations (and see Taylor 2018).
A third option would be that La Via Campesina-type organisations push states to implement food sovereignty principles. Here, a shift in power towards smaller-scale producers, locally orientated production based on increasingly agroecological principles, and reductions in food trade could begin to alter the food system.
A fourth option, which is the most far-fetched at the time of writing, is that workers’ organisations succeed in pushing states, or themselves begin to implement increasingly democratic structures through which food production and consumption can be regulated.
On what basis might such movements emerge? And to what extent should we expect coalitions of different social forces to form? In the USA, the Biden administration brought industrial policy back onto the political agenda with large-scale investments through the inflation reduction act, and other provisions of finance to facilitate a green transition. Variants of a Green Deal in Europe are similarly focused. So far, these have been focused on manufacturing industry – from micro-chip to electric vehicle (EV) production. However, if such investments become part of the new normal under pressure of the spiralling climate crisis, it would not be too surprising if they broadened out to include investing in CSA techniques and technologies. So, the question of whether the state should invest in economic activity moves from a yes/no binary, to a ‘yes, but how’ issue. The Biden administration’s finance provision was driven to a large-extent by geopolitical concerns – aiming to contain China’s rise in high-tech. But if such finance is maintained, even under a Trump administration, it will keep the focus on what it is being used for.
The recent strike, in mid 2023, by the United Auto Workers represents the emergence of a potentially transformatory social force. The Union secured agreements that improved workers’ wages and conditions, and to facilitate unionisation of EV-producing factories. This conjures up the spectre of unionisation drives across the USA and potentially beyond in the ‘green transition’ sector. What if workers’ organisations can continue putting pressure on employers and potentially local and federal states to invest in worker-friendly forms of a green transition, beyond industry? Might such pressure attempt to re-shape agriculture and food production? Might there be a place for high-tech alternatives to meat in such a scenario? Would decommodification of food (and perhaps even land) become part of such a political agenda, with community kitchens and restaurants sourcing local food produced under increasingly democratic agroecological conditions?
It would be relatively easy to imagine a scenario where organised workers and smaller producers united to demand the establishment of a ‘popular’ food system. By the same token, it is even easier to imagine state and big-business collaboration to establish an increasingly authoritarian food system. But what about different coalitions – such as between an authoritarian state and (politically bought off) sections of organised labour? Could food sovereignty movements be co-opted by ‘green’ capital?
As suggested in this blog, the land/agrarian question in the 21st century will become increasingly bound up with the climate question and the broader environment question, and The Journal of Agrarian Change will be well placed to explain such dynamics.
Benjamin Selwyn is Professor of International Relations and International Development at the Department of International Relations, University of Sussex.
This is part of a series of specially curated blog posts in which authors are invited to reflect on the theme of ‘Agrarian Questions’, highlighting different, even novel, ways of interpreting and engaging with the core questions of agrarian political economy in different historical and contemporary contexts. The posts will be released over the coming months as part of the 25th year celebrations of the Journal of Agrarian Change. You can find the full series of blog posts here.
Image by Oregon Department of Agriculture via Flickr